The audit results for magazines for the six months to December 2012 is challenging for many publishers. Marie Claire dropped 9.6%, InStyle 8.2%, Family Circle 33.1% and Men’s Health 2.8% for Pacific Magazines in the monthlies. They’d be very happy with Women’s Health – up .3% facing considerable competition and Better Homes and Gardens – up 2.5%. They’d also be happy with Diabetic Living – up 8.4%.
In the weekly space, New Idea fell 4% and Who 4.6% while Famous rose (again) 2.5%. Overall good numbers here for Pacific.
Bauer had a tougher audit. Cleo dropped 23.6%, Cosmopolitan dropped 16.2%, Madison dropped 23.3% and Shop Til You Drop dropped 14.9%. Tough numbers to face.
In the weeklies, Grazia dropped 24%, Woman’s Day 5.8%, OK! down 11.4%, Zoo Weekly down 18.1% and NW losing 6.9%. This is interesting in the face of the continuing Bauer discount program at train and airport locations and their regular bundling of titles at a discount. While I don’t have detailed data, these sales numbers, compared to like titles from Pacific, indicate the discounting program from Bauer is not working.
The Australian Women’s Weekly sales remained the same – a good result for Bauer in this marketplace. They’d also be happy with Good Health – up .5%, Real Living – up 15.3% and Belle – up 13.4%.
Good news in the audit for Frankie – year on year sales up 5%. The continued Frankie success shows that content is king. Indeed, good, well-targeted, content can support a high ($9.95) cover price without the need for free gifts and other tricks too often used by magazine publishers to drive sales.
I say give the editors more control over the product and the marketers less control. Also, support newsagents more as the magazine specialists – so people can have the time, space and support to fall in love with the medium and specific titles.
Check out the B&T report on the magazine results.