I really did think Groovy Grandmas was a porn title when I first saw it. It’s not, Groovy Grandmas is a good magazine. It appears to hit its demographic. This new title is hard to locate in our vast range and difficult to find space for in an already full fixture. My bigger concern is the financial aspects of this title. NDD decided we should get 19 copies. At $9.95 each, this means we are providing $141 in funding for the launch copy. With a four month on-sale and the space requirements, there is no way we can cover our costs – expecially given that we received no marketing collateral.
NDD gets upset when I point the finger at their broken magazine scale out model. They say that they have a good relationship with the ANF and are working with them on magazine KPIs. Well, this NDD/ANF relationship is now three years old and we still get grossly oversupplied with long shelf life product. Based on Groovy Grandmas a fair assessment would be that NDD will do what NDD wants. On Groovy Grandmas, like other titles, I suspect that NDD is paid for each copy they move. Newsagents shold be on the same terms.
The scale out of this title would be a good test case for the ACCC to review as it demonstrates all that is wrong with the magazine supply model – oversupply, supply not based on sales data and a long shelf life.
Newsagents cannot be the banker for independent publishers and magazine distributors any longer.
We will promote the title for the next couple of weeks but we expect to be early returning at least half what they sent us – probably topped since I should not have to pay the freight for another NDD stuff up.