I thought I’d update how the Herald Sun Australia Day hat promotion panned out for us in our four shopping centre based newsagencies – two I own and two in which I have a 50% share.
In one newsagency we received around 30% more hats than Herald Sun newspapers. This worked well for us. We ran out at around 2pm with some of our newspapers still left to sell and while we faced frustrated customers, by that time of the day they were okay about it. Our distribution newsagent had given us as many as possible.
In another newsagency we didn’t receive any. We approached the supplying newsagent and we had to go pick up the stock. They gave us hats for around half our Herald Sun stock. Since we are outside a busy major supermarket we were, naturally, out of stock within an hour. We called for more stock and while a staff member answering the phone told us they had plenty the newsagent said they had none. Our people spent the rest of the day fending off upset customers.
In our third newsagency we received enough hats for 60% of our Herald Sun stock. We were out by 11am and the newsagent did not have any more stock. Again, upset customers.
In our fourth newsagency we received hats for 30% of our Herald Sun stock. We were out of stock of hats by 10am. The supplying newsagent agreed to give us five more – we had to go and pick them up. they were gone in minutes.. Being right outside a supermarket we were getting hit hard for hats. Plenty of angry customers for the rest of the day.
I don’t know where the supply problem is – with the Herald & Weekly Times or with the supplying newsagent – but I do know that there is a problem and the team at the front counter in newsagencies like mine are left dealing with upset and, occasionally, abusive customers. The damage to the reputation of our business and to the name of the Herald Sun is, in my view, considerable.
I love the Australia day hat promotion but, as is so often the case with newspaper promotions, am highly critical of the execution. What is the point if these things are executed so poorly so often?
I’d like to see the circulation people at the Herald & Weekly Times host a meeting with retail and distribution newsagents and work out a plan which serves customers better. If we get that right then the publisher, the retail newsagent and the distribution newsagent all win.