A blog on issues affecting Australia's newsagents, media and small business generally. More ...

Month: September 2011

Canberra newsagents suffer from freight company change

Canberra newsagents have been hit with missing parcels and late deliveries of magazines and newspapers today as a consequence of Gotch and Network ditching local freight company Murrell’s in favour of Toll.

While the magazine distributors save money on distribution costs, newsagents lose sales.  Time is now being wasted chasing missing parcels.  This is false economy on the part of the magazine distributors.

Newsagents located in NSW, outside the jurisdiction of the ACT, could take this matter to the CTTT.  It could be reasonably straightforward to get a case up against the distributors for taking unilateral action which is detrimental to your business and your customers.

0 likes
magazine distribution

Gordon and Gotch fails newsagents on Simpson comic supply model

mags-bartsimpson.JPGDespite promises that they would address the supply of comics, magazine distributor Gordon and Gotch continues to fail newsagents by supplying to a level where most newsagents lose money carrying the Simpson comics. Take the latest Bart Simpson comic, we should have received 40% less stock than the magazine distribution experts at Gordon and Gotch sent us.

Gordon and Gotch holds us accountable for paying them yet they continue to refuse to be accountable for fair, ethical and responsible supply. The time spent on this, while not massive on only title, adds up and detracts from investing in more successful magazine titles.

Publishers who treat newsagents fairly by supplying to a 60% or more sell through should demand that Gotch stop supplying where their own sales data proves that they are oversupplying.

For the record I note that I consider supplying to anything less than a 60% sell through target is over supply.

Gotch should stop using our newsagencies as warehouses. Supply fewer copies and use sales based replenishment techniques to replenish based on demand. Making the retailer pay the price of an inefficient system is unfair.

Footnote: it’s not only the Simpson’s comics.  Gotch’s own sale and return data has evidence of plenty of oversupply like this.

0 likes
magazine distribution

Chilling employee theft footage

I got to see some chilling video footage on Monday of an employee stealing from the back office of a business run by a newsagent. You can see the employee check that the coast is clear before she reaches for a bundle of $50 notes and stuffs them into her bra. She then grabs $20s and $10s. Of course, with the video evidence there was no doubt a successful conviction.

Too many newsagents say this will not happen to them. They cite employee loyalty, good cash handling processes or that they are in a town where everyone knows everyone else.

We are all at risk and we need to run our businesses accordingly.

Employee theft is real. I estimate that it costs the newsagency channel at least $15 million a year.

0 likes
theft

Magazine publisher to sell subscriptions in beauty outlets

US magazine publisher Condé Nast is to sell magazine subscriptions in a beauty products chain according a report published by the the US edition of Ad Week:

With circulation growth getting harder to come by, Condé Nast is going to the beauty aisle in search of new customers.

The fashion/beauty magazine publisher has struck a deal to sell subscriptions in Ulta, a 415-store beauty products chain, as part of an expansive marketing partnership. Initially, Glamour and Allure are being sold for $21 for a year’s subscription to both. Single copies are available, too. Over time, other Condé titles, which include Vogue and Vanity Fair, may be substituted.

With Australian publishers following US trends I wonder how soon we will see this here?  We already see some titles being sold in bulk to hair and other outlets, why not subscriptions?

0 likes
magazine distribution

Smith Journal reader feedback

Check out this feedback from a reader of the recently launched Smith Journal.  Read his comments about where it was located in the newsagency:

I was amazed at your first issue, the photography, the articles, the whole look and feel of the magazine. There is finally something that I am comfortable with reading, every single article is well written and individual in its own way. You truly have created something that is unique.

It would be great however if it was published more that once every 6 months, because now I don’t have anything to read, for 6 months.

The IQ Test was my favourite article, even though I could only get 3/5 for the practice one.

Keep up the great work!

PS. I found it slightly humorous that this magazine was placed next to the body building and sex mags at my local newsagent!

The recommended location for Smith Journal as advised to newsagents is: frankie for the first week, then with Special Interest, Current Affairs, Lifestyle & Fashion, Art & Literature, Photography & Culture.

0 likes
magazines

Promoting the outdoor room

mags-outdooroom-oct11.JPGWe are promoting the latest issue of the outdoor room in one of my newsagencies with this aisle end display facing into the women’s / home magazine area.

We are also going to give the title a run on the weekend next to newspapers where it is certain to pick up incremental business – especially with Spring here. I’d urge newsagents to seek out this title for special treatment in the first week or two of the on-sale period.

With Jamie Durie back on TV, albeit on a different network, there’s an opportunity to leverage this to support the magazine.

0 likes
magazines

Leveraging the 3D content in SHOP til you drop

mags-shoptil.JPGI love this display promoting the latest issue of SHOP til you drop created by the team at one of my newsagencies earlier this week.

Through clever selection of backing colours and the use of layering of materials they have connected the display with the 3D content in the magazine.

It is hard to innovate beyond design and content in a magazine so it’s good to see ACP playing with 3D in their popular shopping magazine.  It gives irregular purchasers a reason to pick up this issue.

We are promoting the latest issue of SHOP til you drop with this display at the front of the newsagency, in a highly visible location. We’ll give it a week here. It’s also located in the usual location with fashion titles.

We are happy to give our shoppers a chance to browse the 3D experience – offering glasses for customers to try before they buy.

0 likes
magazines

News Limited makes an odd distribution change for The Australian

Newsagents in Albury no longer get The Australian delivered by trucks from the News’ Victorian business the Herald and Weekly Times.  Instead, The Australian is being delivered by News’ NSW business Nationwide News.  Woodonga, 2km away, still gets The Australian from H&WT.

This change will see The Australian no longer available for consistent home delivery as Nationwide News deliveries to Albury are consistently too late for home delivery.  H&WT deliveries were on time for home delivery.  Oh, there are enough copies of The Australian for supermarkets on an early truck from Nationwide.

The switch is an odd decision if the company really does want to sell more newspapers.

0 likes
newspaper home delivery

Network and Gotch ditch ACT freight company after 25 years

Network and Gotch have ceased using Murrell’s in the ACT for the distribution of magazines after 25 years of service.  Both companies have switched to Toll.  I am told that newsagents are now faced with higher return costs if they switch to Toll for this as well.  Many are contacting Murrell’s to continue the returns arrangements.

It seems that great service is not enough to maintain a contract with Gotch and Network.   I feel for the families relying on Murrell’s for their income.

0 likes
magazine distribution

Proof of a sick newspaper home delivery model in Australia

A newsagent colleague handed back their newspaper home delivery territory two years ago.  The distribution business was turning over in excess of $500,000 a year but was losing money and detratcing from the associated retail business.

The publisher appointed a contractor to replace the newsagent.  They handed the distribution business back after a year.

The publisher appointed another contractor.  They have just pulled out due to the run being loss-making.

The publisher has now taken on then run for themselves.  Maybe they will realise, like the three before them, that their unreasonable and socially irresponsible approach to newspaper home delivery is what is killing newspaper home delivery businesses in Australia.

Publishers cannot expect newsagents to carry an unreasonable share of the cost cutting which is driven by subscription and other deals.

It is unfair that newsagents work for below minimum wage when publishers increase advertising rates and protect their own position.

The story I have shared is playing out beyond this one location because we have a situation where publishers protect their income through advertising rates yet refuse to give small business newsagents an opportunity to achieve a fair income through newspaper home delivery charges.

This is why newsagents are handing back their runs.

0 likes
Ethics

Reader’s Digest oversupply continues

mags-readerd.JPGMy estimate is that Reader’s Digest magazine has a sell through rate of around 25%. This is my experience in at least one of my newsagencies. It is a poor performing title yet the magazine distribution experts at Network Services decided I should get an increase in supply. While they will have their excuses, I see no justification in my sales data for them sending more copies of Reader’s Digest. All their action achieves is taking up valuable time dealing with the unjustified supply quantity, taking time from more productive magazine management work.

Looking carefully at the sale and return data, it seems to me that Network will increase supply if you have one good month but they will wait for three or four bad months before decreasing supply.  This suggests double standards.  It is not, in my view, fair or responsible. They are spending my money, giving me little control and expecting me to pay their accounts on time without being fair or ethical about it.

Publishers who supply more fairly, to achieve a sell through of 60% or more, are being hampered by whatever it is which sees newsagents supplied titles like Reader’s Digest with such a more sell through rate. The good publishers should be demanding of their magazine distributors. There is proof in distributor data of gross oversupply – if only you could get your hands on it.

0 likes
magazine distribution

Chasing growth in kids magazines

mags-spiderkids.JPGWe are promoting a selection of kids magazines with the latest issue of the Bugs and Insects partwork. We are still seeing good traffic for Bugs so it made sense to me to try and drive impulse purchases of these other titles on the back of the Bugs traffic. I appreciate that sales of kids titles are dropping, this does not mean that we should not promote them. Hopefully, our tactical placement generates for us a bit of extra business.

0 likes
magazines

Donald Trump wants us all to be rich … who cares?

The full and half page ads promoting the loftily titled National Achiever’s Congress featuring Donald Trump read a bit like a scam to me. The ads are full of hype-drenched text.

For a discounted price of less than half of their claimed ‘value’ we can sit through three days of money-making experts.  I wonder how much of the three days will have Trump on stage.  An hour or so I am guessing.

Like I said, the ads read like a scam. I’ve watched Trump on his TV show and seen him interviewed many times. I can’t recall any business advice he could give which would help an Australian small business owner.

Too often businesses are told to look elsewhere for guidance and answers on the big questions. Besides Trump, we are told to get mentors, business advisors and the like to guide us. Of course, the people telling us to look elsewhere are usually those who want us to pay them money to help with this.

The best advice we can get is that which we can give to ourselves, by being the business leaders we should be as owners of our own businesses.

I have seen excellent business leaders emerge from their own times of challenge, without having to spend money on imported celebrities to guide them.  What can Donald Trump tell us which is relevant anyway?  he lives in a very different world to us small business people.  His friends and networks are completely foreign to us.  There is little relevance or connection between his community and ours.

I think this Donald Trump headlining National Achiever’s Congress is a waste of money.

0 likes
Newsagency management

Tyro fights for newsagents on looming EFTPOS fee hike

Click here to see a press release issued on Friday last week by Tyro, the broadband EFTPOS processing business loved by newsagents. This press release continues to raise the issue of fairness as embodied by this quote from Jost Stollmann, CEO of Tyro.

“We certainly consider it unfair for Australia’s shops to face the risk of up to 10 cents higher eftpos costs, when Coles and Woolworths continue to be paid 5 cents for each of their eftpos transactions.”

I think it’s unfair too. It looks like the banks are about to rip us off – added and abetted by the Reserve Bank plus Coles and Woolworths.

My question for newsagents is – what have you done to fight about this. I know that some of you have … but not enough. Every newsagent should be incensed about this and lobbying their bank and local politicians. Come October 1 it will be too late.

In the meantime, I’d encourage newsagents to switch from their current bank EFTPOS provider to Tyro – you’re likely to save money. Most newsagency systems interface directly to Tyro.

0 likes
EFTPOS fees

I don’t want Eating and Drinking Melbourne

masg-eatmelb.JPGNetwork Services sent me two copies of Eating and Drinking Melbourne – showing off a problem with the magazine distribution model. I don’t want this title. It’s expensive. We have a more popular title on our shelves. It’s a theft risk. It wastes my money.

While the folks at network will say that I shouldn’t complain since I can early return the title, they are not paying for the labour and other costs associated with this. They really have no idea of the costs involved with their ill-considered scale out decisions.

If the accounts people at Network want me to be responsible for my level of indebtedness then they need to give me better control over the level of indebtedness which I incur. Otherwise, how can I be reasonably held accountable?

0 likes
magazine distribution

Cheeky National Australia Bank

nab.JPGSomeone from the National Australia Bank visited one of my newsagencies on the weekend asking staff to place this flyer on the counter for customers.

For an organisation as controlled by processes as a bank, I am surprised at the casual, lazy even, way they expected us to be part of their marketing campaign.

The NAB charges for you to use their ATM, if you are not a customer did not offer us anything for helping them out.

We are not a NAB customer so there should have been a cost – following their fee logic.  It seems that they expect us to be generous with our time and space while refusing to be generous themselves.

And banks wonder why we don’t like them!

0 likes
Ethics

Promoting the Flat Belly Diet with Prevention magazine

mags-prevention.JPGWe are promoting the flat belly diet guide which comes free with the latest issue of Prevention magazine. This is an excellent free gift and is sure to drive a surge in sales – as long as newsagents promote Prevention in a high-traffic location.

This is what we are doing – we have Prevention located at the counter as well as in its usual location. In each instance we are ensuring that the full cover is on show – showing off the flat belly diet free gift. I think this is key to driving incremental business for the title.

0 likes
magazines

Newsagency Management and Marketing Tip: Own your point of difference

While I have written here about the need for newsagencies to have a point of difference, a unique selling proposition, my sense is that most newsagents ignore this, considering it to be a waste of time.

Sadly, I think too many newsagents live with the mindset that it is our channel which is difference and therefore our USP.  Certainly, we are unique in the world.  Okay, there are newsagencies in the UK, but they are not the newspaper / magazine / greeting cards / stationery channel that we are.

The reality is that our channel is not unique., not at all.

Everything we sell is available elsewhere, often in just one or two shops.  Check out your local supermarket or Big W, K Mart or target store.  I bet that around 90% of your non gambling product sales could be satisfied from these much bigger, more aggressive and better known competitors.

Twenty or thirty years ago we were unique.  We were protected and we loved it. The bubble of protection has burst.  We are on our own.

In today’s world and with our stronger than ever competitors, we MUST stand for something, each of us in our own newsagencies.  We can’t do it as a channel because we would never work together to an agreed standard.

I have a suggestion for you: take some time to stand in front of your shop and on your shop floor and contemplate what it is that your business stands for and consider whether you see and feel that point of difference being embraced in how you are running the business.

Your USP must be obvious from outside your newsagency and within.  It must be felt and experiences at the counter, on the phone, in your newsletter, in your community work, on your vehicles and through your product mix and your people.

Is your USP, your point of difference, obvious to your customers?

Now more than ever, with the national retailers pursuing our businesses with aggression we have never seen before, we, each of us, MUST nail our USP,  otherwise we will fade in the minds of shoppers and with that fading we will see a retreat of foot traffic.

I am concerned that not enough newsagents get the importance of this, of standing for something, of offering something which is unique … something so tangible and appreciated that your shoppers tell their friends about it.

I got hooked on the British comedy series The Inbetweeners a few months ago.   It’s hilarious.  The sitcom genre is a challenge, too often characters blend into each other and those involved in the show get lazy – this is true for many US sitcoms.  Also, laughs are often too cheap.  The Inbetweeners can shock you and make you laugh all at once, even after three series. I love this show so much that I told people, plenty of people.  I know that they have told people. You can see where I am going.  Word of mouth has a powerful ripple effect.

Don’t you want to unleash the power of word of mouth for your business?  Your point of difference is key to this happening.

You don’t get good word of mouth for your newsagency if you do not nail, embrace, live and drive your point of difference.  It is vitally important to loyalty.

So when you are in front of your shop or on your shop floor, think about this – what is it that you do or sell which is so compelling and appreciated that your customers will tell their friends?

I can’t stress enough the importance of resolving this for your newsagency.

No one can tell you what your point of difference should be.  You must discover this for yourself, from within your newsagency, working with your team.  Once you have made your decision, everything you do in your business should be done with your point of difference in your mind.

Sorting this out is one of the biggest challenges for newsagents and the channel as a whole.  Get this right and even the smallest of newsagencies can grow and know tremendous success.

FOOTNOTE: If you think you have your point of difference sorted out, check with your customers and find out what they think.

0 likes
Newsagency challenges

Featuring Home Beautiful magazine

mags-homebeautiful.JPGWe have giving Home Beautiful double pocket space for the first week so that the free celebrity chef recipe book with this issue is easily seen by browsers.

I figured we are better off making use of the premium packaging as it is designed for this type of merchandising – even though most retailers would not allocate the extra space to enable it to be opened out as we have done.

0 likes
magazines

Promoting Symply Too Good

smply-watergardens.JPGWe have been promoting Annette Sym’s Symply Too Good range in another of my newsagencies with success.  This display on a column is at the front of the newsagency – it is seen by shoppers as they go to leave the store.  It shows off the range and makes it easy for shoppers to browse each title.  Click on the image to see a larger version of this phone.

0 likes
magazines

EPAL retreats on EFTPOS feek hike position

As I have been writing here for some time, EFTPOS fees are set to increase from October thanks to a decision by EPAL, the organisation created by the Reserve Bank and controlled by the major banks plus Coles and Woolworths.  Oh, and I have noted that Coles and Woolowrths are set to not face any fee hike. Why the Reserve Bank would think it is smart to put the big banks and Coles and Woolworths in charge of the cookie jar given their addiction is beyond me.  What is even more shocking is that no one in the government is prepared to reasonable engage on this as an issue of concern for small business.

Anyway, I digress.

Yesterday, it was reported that EPAL has changed its position on the impact of its EFTPOS fee pricing decision.  Here is what EPAL had said:

Australian consumers should not face new charges to eftpos interchange fees.

Yesterday, the Australian Financial Review reported (page 48) EPAL as saying:

It is therefore premature to state with certainty what impact the planned changes will have on retailers or then upon their consumers.

Click here to read the full EPAL press release containing this quote.  Not that it says much.  It’s a kind of a cover your backside press release, as if they know what is coming.

I suspect that the EPAL Board, controlled by the big banks plus Coles and Woolworths and realised that the big banks will pass on increased fees and that retailers will either have to either suck these up or pass them on.  With the current retail challenges, it’s far less likely that retailers would have the capacity to suck up the EPAL / Bank drives fee increases.

This back down by EPAL is considerable given the battle they have waged over recent months against anyone who has criticised their new fee regime.  They have successfully nobbled politicians based on the responses I have seen from local members who have been queried by newsagents about the new interchange fees.

It is not too late for newsagents to engage on this issue.  The ANF and a small group of newsagents have.  If only more newsagents would.

For background on this issue and a copy of a letter from the ANF which you can use, please click here.

0 likes
EFTPOS fees

An opportunity for newsagents with Quarterly Essay: Bad News by Robert Manne

mags-quarterly.JPGWe have tactically placed the latest issue of Quarterly Essay – Bad News by Robert Manne – at the front of the newsagency, next to newspapers.  This title usually resides toward the back of the business, with Time and other low volume news related magazines.

Manne’s essay is about News Corporation, Rupert Murdoch’s political voice in Australia, The Australian newspaper and how it shapes debate.

We have placed Quarterly Essay next to The Age as e are more likely to get a reader of The Age purchasing this on impulse than a Herald Sun reader.  I’m hoping we sell out.

I’d urge newsagents to try placing this issue at the counter.  A $19.95 addition to any shopping basket would be most welcome!

0 likes
magazines