I have been talking with newsagents recently who made changes to their card supply arrangements which have resulted in them being worse off.
One newsagent switched from one the major card companies to a smaller company on the claim that sales would increase and the offer of a margin boost. Their sales, year on year, are down 25% following the move. The extra 5% margin they negotiated is worth nothing. They are worse off. It is easy for a card company to offer a bag of cash or a boost in margin. The harder road is to help you boos sales. However, boosting sales is better for you.
Another newsagent went from 100% with one company to 75%. The net increase in sales year on year was 2%. However, the sales drop for their main supplier, due to 25% less pockets, resulted in the newsagents dropping to a lower rebate grouping. Financially, they are considerably worse off. A lack of research leading up to making the decision has resulted in them losing money.
Some card company sales representatives are less than accurate when outlining hat a switch to their business would mean for the newsagent.
My advice to newsagents is caveat emptor, let the buyer beware.
- Take your time, talk to newsagents who have moved. Ask for details of the financial impact.
- Get every claim and every offering writing and signed by senior management of the company with authority to sign.
- If you are moving because of unhappiness with your current arrangements, take time to ensure that your existing supplier is afforded every opportunity to fix any problems.
- Get a written guarantee on the financial benefit of the move.
The two newsagents I have worked with don’t have anything to go off and cannot therefore easily get out of their worse-off situation.